The Ministry of Justice of Armenia has submitted a draft of amendments to the Civil Code for public discussion. The initiative is aimed at establishing mandatory minimum thresholds for monetary compensation for insults, slander, torture, and violations of the right to life. According to the department, current norms do not provide for adequate compensation for damages commensurate with the severity of the harm caused.
New standards for compensation for damages
Photo: Beko / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0
Currently, the legislation limits the maximum amount of payments for insults to 3 million drams, and for slander to 6 million drams, but there are no minimum thresholds. The proposed draft law maintains the existing "ceilings" but introduces a mandatory lower limit for payments. The ministry emphasizes that the goal of the changes is not only to protect victims but also to strengthen the accountability of state bodies.
Priority of non-pecuniary measures
Photo: Cozyboar2003 / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0
Relying on the 2011 Constitutional Court decision, representatives of the Ministry of Justice noted that financial compensation should not be automatic or punitive in nature. Courts are still recommended to prioritize non-pecuniary means of protecting rights, such as public apologies, retractions, or the publication of court decisions. Monetary payments should be awarded only in cases where other measures are insufficient to restore justice.
Protection of rights in cases of serious violations
Special attention in the draft is paid to cases of torture and violations of the right to life. The department emphasized that the overturning of an unlawful verdict or holding the perpetrators criminally liable does not always compensate for the damage caused to the health or reputation of the victim. In this regard, it is proposed to remove the upper limit of compensation for victims of torture.
According to the document, courts will continue to consider each case individually, assessing the nature and duration of the violations. The final decision on the amount of payments will be made within the framework of the new threshold values established by law.
Monitoring of the Dzorak center revealed violations of sanitary standards, a lack of an accessible environment, and the need for reform of the guardianship system.